Design for black-and-white printing

Colour figures in journal articles are common these days. Many of the people reading them, however, will print them in black and white. Consequently, when designing figures, we should ensure they remain meaningful if converted to grayscale. Here are a few tips to keep in mind.

Use different line styles (and weights)

Different colours are a good way to distinguish different lines. However, the time-tested method of using different line styles (dashed, dotted, etc) is more reliable. The best option is to distinguish by colour and style as the example shows.

colour_linestyle
Lines identifiable by both their colour and style

Using different line weights (thicknesses) can augment the number of distinct lines available. However, be careful to ensure the reader doesn’t infer anything you didn’t intend, e.g., that thicker lines relate to more important quantities.

Use varying brightness

Certain colour schemes can be converted to grayscale and have their components remain identifiable by virtue of their brightnesses (also known as value or lightness). Typically, these schemes start with closely related colours. For example, red, orange, and yellow are related in that they are warm colours and are adjacent on a colour wheel. Careful tinting or shading (mixing with white or black) results in a colour scheme with evenly separated shades of gray when printed without colour.

colour_grayscale
Two colour schemes that remain meaningful when converted to grayscale

For line graphs, these colour schemes are beneficial for situations where dashed and dotted lines would not work well. Note, however, that a practical upper limit to the number of lines that can be distinguished this way is five. Any more than that and the reader will be unable to accurately differentiate between lines.

For filled contour plots, these schemes are appropriate for sequential (as opposed to diverging) data. A reasonable limit on the number of different shades is eight.

Use dashed lines for negative contours

In an earlier post, I recommended the blue–red colourmap as one possibility for diverging data. Unfortunately, when printed in black and white, information about the sign is lost; only the magnitude is shown. For contour plots, this can be overcome by using the following established convention: solid lines for positive contours and dashed lines for negative contours. Here’s an example:

dashed_contour
Solid and dashed contour lines and contour labels provide a back up for black-and-white printing

It might appear that the inline contour labels make the need for dashed contour lines redundant. However, the dashed lines help demarcate the positive and negative regions. This is useful for illustrating the overall structure of the data.

dashed_contour_bw
Converting the colour image above to grayscale highlights the importance of the dashed contour lines
Advertisements

Author: hugke729

PhD student in physical oceanography

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s